Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
100 WILLIAM ST
New York
NY 10038
United States

Average rating: 9.5 out of 10 based on 197 ratings.

What our clients/members think of us!

The following comments were submitted by our customers when asked to provide feedback on our service. In the interest of transparency, we present these comments as provided except that personally identifiable information has been hidden unless the reviewer has requested their full name be included with the review. No unfavorable comments have been removed.

Report a concern   October 7, 2023 — Rated 7 out of 10 by P.K. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What could we do to improve?

Shoutout to head coach Bethany for going above and beyond to elevate members’ experiences!

Report a concern   October 5, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by R.G. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Everything

Report a concern   September 22, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by J.T. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Love the energy, the encouragement and the non-shaming aspect. I'm middle aged and not trying to be a meat head. I feel like I get an intense, efficient and well rounded work out that's social, fun and always different.

Report a concern   September 20, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by T.V. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

They are well balanced and allow for both fat loss and muscle building.

Report a concern   September 18, 2023 — Rated 9 out of 10 by L.S. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Great team, knowable coaches.

Report a concern   September 15, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Joshua Calliste Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

I absolutely love working out at the OTF- FiDi location. The team is always inviting and willing to help. Coach Bethany is AMAZING and I love taking her class as she brings a vibrant energy and attitude to each session.

Report a concern   August 25, 2023 — Rated 9 out of 10 by Alfredo Della Monica Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Coaches are amazing, staff is super friendly and the festive, positive vibe at the studio is really encouraging for everyone! Great job Orangetheory FiDi!

Report a concern   August 24, 2023 — Rated 0 out of 10 by R.P. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
How did we disappoint you and what can we do to make things right?

Not a great experience. I joined on Tuesday and started my 30-day notice period to quit on Thursday. While I loved the workout, the feel is... mindless corporate franchise. Better to end the relationship early.

The reason I quit today was that I was running a little late for the 7:10 class - only my second time doing this subway route at this time of day, and I left at the same time as Tuesday, but (trial and error) it took 10-15 minutes longer today. I called when I got off the train around 7:13 and said I was 2-3 minutes away. The desk attendant mentioned the 5-minute cut-off but acknowledged that it was my second class and said something along the lines of "do your best to get here quickly, we'll take care of you." Her gave the definite impression sense that if I raced to get there in the next few minutes, they'd let me into the class. So I did, walked in at 7:16 and he and the other attendant told me I couldn't go into the class. (Class was nowhere near full either.) In response to my respectfully expressed annoyance at the poor communication and the overall sequence of events, his colleague pointedly asked me if I wanted to use my one free class cancellation for this - this felt unnecessarily passive aggressive at worst and like a poor timing at best. That is when I decided to cancel.

Policies are policies, but timing, discretion and customer-relationship building are much, much more important. Anyone who has ever worked in a customer-oriented environment would have recognized that this was an appropriate time to set the policy aside with minimal downside to doing so. As a brand new member, eager and excited to get a workout routine going after months of working in a high-stress environment, it was a big disappointment to realize that a business that offers a good product but doesn't empower its employees to use their discretion (or fails to train them to do so effectively) is not going to be a fit for me.

I was also a little annoyed when, after I bought my package I found out that I had to buy the heart rate monitor, which is pricey. (In the drop-in class, they had loaned me one, so I did not realize that it wasn't included, and it was never mentioned.) Another example of a missed opportunity to be communication and customer-experience oriented.

Re the monitor, I have never used it - had only just opened the box as I walked in this morning - and (not surprising), the same front desk employee sheepishly told me he could not accept it as a return without his manager's approval.

How you can make it right: Accept the return of the unused arm band. Refund a portion of my first month's membership - I only took a single class and now I am back to the drawing board in looking for a group class that meets my needs. A gracious response to this unfortunate experience would keep my mind open in terms of reconsidering becoming an OT member in the future and would be the sort of resolution that would balance out the negative experience.

Report a concern   August 17, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Jose Loera Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

I love Orange Theory Fidi! The coaches and classes are challenging and you actually see results. Not to mention the community of people behind it really are motivating. Couldn't recommend enough!

Report a concern   August 16, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Mahmoud Shouman Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Things I like:

- Staff and management pleasantness
- Studio cleanliness and equipment function
- Trainer expertise and attitude
- Effective workouts
- Community building

Report a concern   August 6, 2023 — Rated 9 out of 10 by Rahul Modi Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

A really well rounded workout that focuses on keeping your cardiovascular health up while also maintaining strength

Report a concern   August 4, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Dani Cook Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

I like the structure and pace of the workout. The coaches are supportive as well.

Report a concern   July 27, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Christopher OConnor Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

It is a fabulous program, gym is always clean and instructors are always on point!

Report a concern   July 24, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Mikaiel Naqvi Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

I love how genuine everyone is from the front desk to inside the class. It’s a great community of people I would actually hang out with outside of class as well. As for the workout itself, the coach really takes the time to get to know you and in class knows exactly how to push you so you’re achieving your best every time. Don’t have enough good things to say about this studio!

Report a concern   July 23, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Matthew Goldstein Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

I love the people there

Report a concern   July 10, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by M.W. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

It's a fun and supportive group environment with the right level of competition against yourself, not against others.
Trainers are great which makes you feel like you're going to see friends each class!
Plus, the orange lights in the studio are great!

Report a concern   July 10, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by T.H. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

All of the coaches at this studio are top notch, each with their different style, but always fun and engaging. The front desk staff are all friendly, encouraging and seem to know the members who attend here and this makes a difference. I appreciate very much that their equipment is new, the studio is spacious, locker areas are clean and most importantly I never struggle to book a class here whether in advance or last minute. I especially love that they have towels here--this truly is a great perk. Many studios that I have been to do not, and I belong to this location because I feel that I truly get a good value for the elite membership monthly cost, as it is managed very well. I recently made it to 100 classes, and the staff were supportive, and even posted it on their IG page.

Report a concern   July 8, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by P.L. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

The coaches and the 45 lift class

Report a concern   June 15, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by J.T. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Quick, brainless and fun.

Report a concern   June 9, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Joshua Calliste Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Since joining, I’ve felt like I’ve gained the support of not just my coach but an entire community. I love the energy of Bethany and the entire team!

Report a concern   June 9, 2023 — Rated 8 out of 10 by M.K. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What could we do to improve?

- Orange theory is not really for all levels. It is definitely not for beginners and I wish it was more clear. I see a lot of people with terrible form and the coaches can only do so much during a session. I would recommend having a few beginner sessions that are slower and go through form.
- Crunches and Sit ups are extremely outdated but I still see various versions of them sprinkled in every so often.
- Not all coaches provide alternatives for exercises.
- The gym is very crowded, could be good to reduce by 1 or 2 stations.

Report a concern   May 17, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Gabby Miller Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

I love that it's always a challenge and the coaches motivate you to be your best and reach your fitness goals!

Report a concern   May 15, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Alfredo Della Monica Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Mix of cardio and floor is great! Maybe I would throw in some specific sessions on mobility!

Report a concern   May 4, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Rahul Modi Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

The workout is as well rounded as any that you can have for an hour, with a good balance between cardio and resistance. The coaches are friendly but will push you to challenge and better yourself. The staff is friendly and helpful and I love the community - these are now friends inside and outside of class!

Report a concern   May 2, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by K.M. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Challenges
Training for challenges
Alt-rock pop and taylor swift remixes.

Report a concern   May 1, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Brian Diana Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

It is always different and always challenging

Report a concern   April 22, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by Matthew Goldstein Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

love everyone there.

Report a concern   April 17, 2023 — Rated 6 out of 10 by M.S. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
How did we disappoint you and what can we do to make things right?

Hi, I would like to change my score to 10. There is a lock symbol on the form that wont allow me to update the score.

Report a concern   April 17, 2023 — Rated 10 out of 10 by E.C. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What do you like about our workout?

Supportive coaches, great music and options

Report a concern   April 17, 2023 — Rated 8 out of 10 by P.K. Orangetheory Fitness Manhattan-FIDI, NY
What could we do to improve?

It would be really awesome if there could somehow be incorporated more pilates-like movements in the floor section work of the classes. Also would be really nice to dedicate more time to stretching, specifically the calves since we run so much in class.


Privacy Policy